Advertisement

Crow McAdam challenges three game ban

Adelaide forward Shane McAdam is set to repeat his ‘fair bump’ defence when challenging his three-game ban at the AFL appeals board on Thursday night.

 

Mar 23, 2023, updated Mar 23, 2023
Adelaide's Shane McAdam. Photo: AAP/Darren England

Adelaide's Shane McAdam. Photo: AAP/Darren England

McAdam and his team will again try to get a downgrading of his hit on GWS’ Jacob Wehr which resulted in suspension at a Tuesday night tribunal hearing.

The Crows’ appeal on Thursday evening will be keenly watched by players and officials amid claims of match review inconsistency.

McAdam’s ban follows a two-game suspension on Melbourne’s Kysaiah Pickett for a similar bump which felled Western Bulldog Bailey Smith.

The Crows could again use video of Pickett’s hit as part of their defence – the star Demon’s bump was graded on a lower scale by match review officer Michael Christian.

That meant Pickett was offered a two-game ban and avoided a tribunal hearing while McAdam was sent directly to the tribunal.

Tribunal chairman Jeff Gleeson, when announcing McAdam’s ban on Tuesday, noted in the Pickett case “there appears to be a slightly more glancing aspect to the impact than occurred here”.

Adelaide argued McAdam’s contact was to the chest and shoulder of Wehr, who passed a concussion test and played on.

Coaches were adamant the McAdam and Pickett suspensions, and a one-game ban to Sydney’s Lance Franklin for a high hit, confirmed the end of using the bump.

“The bump is well and truly done,” Carlton coach Michael Voss said.

InDaily in your inbox. The best local news every workday at lunch time.
By signing up, you agree to our User Agreement andPrivacy Policy & Cookie Statement. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

“… If you have got a choice to tackle or bump, then you’ve got no choice but to choose the tackle.”

Geelong’s premiership coach Chris Scott agreed.

“Anything that looks like you’re trying to pick off an opposition player is the game of yesterday. That’s gone,” he said.

-AAP

Local News Matters
Advertisement
Copyright © 2024 InDaily.
All rights reserved.