The SANFL tribunal has found the most appropriate outcome would be to replay the game, but it doesn’t have the power to make such a ruling.
North Adelaide had an extra player on the field for almost four minutes in the final quarter in Sunday’s preliminary final against the Eagles.
North won by five points but admitted the extra-man mistake.
The Eagles protested to the SANFL, which referred the controversy to the league’s independent one-man tribunal, retired Supreme Court judge Michael David QC.
After a five-hour hearing on Monday night, David said the most suitable outcome would be a re-match, but he didn’t have the power to make that ruling.
“To me, a re-match would seem to be the most appropriate penalty but I have no power to do so,” he said.
“I’m of the view that as this was not deliberate a reversal of the result is too savage a penalty.
“The matter should be dealt with by matter of fine and loss of premiership points for next year.
“Sadly, this is of little consolation to the Woodville-West Torrens Football Club.”
David fined North $10,000, the maximum amount under league rules, and also docked the club four premiership points – the equivalent of two wins – next season.
North will play Norwood in Sunday’s grand final.
Last Sunday, North kicked 1.2 – eight points in total – while they had the extra player on the field for three minutes and 39 seconds in the last quarter.
Eagles officials complained to a reserve umpire and interchange stewards about North’s extra player.
But under SANFL rules, only a captain or acting captain can ask an on-field umpire for a head count of players to officially determine an extra-man breach.
It’s understood North called the extra player off the field before the Eagles’ captain could ask a field umpire for a head count.
Help our journalists uncover the facts
In times like these InDaily provides valuable, local independent journalism in South Australia. As a news organisation it offers an alternative to The Advertiser, a different voice and a closer look at what is happening in our city and state for free. Any contribution to help fund our work is appreciated. Please click below to donate to InDaily.