InDaily InDaily

Support independent Journalism Donate Subscribe
Support independent journalism


More political bickering over Aboriginal health clinic left in limbo


Bickering over funding responsibility continues to cloud the future of a dilapidated Aboriginal health clinic in Ceduna, with Labor accusing the Marshall Government of misrepresenting the building’s ownership, while the Premier says it’s not the state’s job to fund an upgrade despite SA Health owning the current site.

Print article

It comes after Marshall said “the taxpayers of South Australia should be extraordinarily concerned” by a Labor pledge this week to spend over $15.85 million to replace the Yadu Health Aboriginal Corporation building if it wins the state and federal elections.

InDaily last year reported concerns from Yadu Health’s leaders that the 50-year-old building was a “ticking time-bomb” and an “accident waiting to happen”.

The not-for-profit Aboriginal community-controlled health service said between 30 to 40 per cent of the building from which it operates free of charge is deemed “unsafe” due to water damage, asbestos and mould.

But despite repeated pleas to the state and federal governments, the health organisation was unable to secure funding to upgrade its facilities.

During yesterday’s SA Press Club leaders’ debate, Labor leader Peter Malinauskas asked Marshall why South Australians should be concerned about an investment in Yadu Health.

“Because it’s a Commonwealth building,” Marshall responded.

“It’s a Commonwealth building that you’re going to be replacing and we think that the Commonwealth has responsibility for that.

“That’s our position – we’ll play our part in it – but it’s certainly not the responsibility of the state taxpayers to foot the bill for something that the Commonwealth should be paying for.”

However, SA Health confirmed to InDaily in July last year that it owns the building.

“We have granted Yadu Health a 99-year lease of the land at their current site to enable them to apply for a Commonwealth Government grant to construct a new building,” a spokesperson said at the time.

A storm caused the clinic’s ceiling to collapse a few years ago. Photo: Supplied

Inside the Yadu Health building last year before repairs. The service says it constantly has to fix mould and water damage in the building. Photo: Supplied

Labor’s Aboriginal Affairs spokesperson Kyam Maher said Marshall’s comments were “demonstratably false”.

“To say you’re not taking action to help some of the most disadvantaged South Australians on the basis of wrong and false information is just reprehensible in my view,” he told InDaily.

“Either he is that misinformed that he just doesn’t know who owns the building… or he’s deliberately not told the truth.”

Maher, who visited Yadu Health on Wednesday, described the building as an “absolute disgrace”.

“The building is falling down, it’s got crumbling asbestos, black mould and just a few weeks ago during heavy rain one of the workers was electrocuted when they tried to use one of the sockets at their work station,” he said.

“It needs repairing – there is no question about that.”

Asked this morning why he said the building was Commonwealth-owned, Marshall said: “Aboriginal community health is a function of the federal government”.

“We have made an offer to the federal government to support the land for them to put a new building on that site,” he said.

“That building is the responsibility of the federal government, not the state government.”

Premier Steven Marshall speaking to reporters at this morning’s launch of the redeveloped Festival Plaza. Photo: Tony Lewis/InDaily

Marshall said the “current building” is owned by SA Health and he was “absolutely certain” that a new building was required, “but the building that they’re looking to build – $10 million investment – is a federal government building”.

“They need to do that work,” he said.

“We will and we have offered to provide that land for that building to go ahead.

“We’ve got plenty of collaboration with the federal government, but with regards to that new building, that is a federal government’s responsibility.”

Marshall said Yadu Health Aboriginal Corporation had done an “outstanding job” keeping their community safe during the coronavirus pandemic.

Of the $15.85 pledged by Labor to upgrade Yadu Health’s clinic, $2.5 million would come from state taxpayers, with that funding to be used to build space for allied health services and dental at a new federal-funded Yadu Health building.

Maher said the $2.5 million would be “completely budgeted for in our costings that will come out before the election”.

The Morrison Government in August pledged to spend $254.4 million on Aboriginal health infrastructure upgrades as part of its Closing the Gap program, but it is yet to provide a slice of that funding to Yadu Health.

In response to questions from InDaily last month, a spokesperson from the federal Health Department said the government was “aware that many Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Services (ACCHS) across the country have deteriorating or limited health infrastructure”.

Health Minister Stephen Wade told parliament in September that he visited the Yadu Health clinic and he thought the facilities were “unacceptable” and “ripe for redevelopment”.

“I think it is important to appreciate that the Yadu Health Aboriginal Corporation is an Aboriginal community-controlled health service, and is funded through the Indigenous Australians health program, and receives more than 70 per cent of its funding from the Commonwealth Government,” he said.

It comes as Labor accused the Marshall Government of an “embarrassing costings bungle”.

Opposition spokesman Tom Koutsantonis said that Premier Steven Marshall told media on February 24 that he was spending $500m on health initiatives.

But at Thursday’s debate between with Labor leader Peter Malinauskas, Marshall said that his government’s announced policies to date cost less than $300 million. 

“Steven Marshall can’t get his story straight when it comes to costings,” Koutsantonis said.

“One day he is spending $500 million on health, the next day he says he is spending less than $300 million in total.”

Asked about the discrepancy this morning, Marshall said the Liberal Party was “always best to manage the finances, always best to manage the economy in South Australia”.

“There was $200 million that went immediately into the budget, so that won’t be post-election,” he said.

“We need to put that money in immediately so that we can continue our well-class response to the coronavirus.

“In total (there’s) $500 million going into our health commitments at this budget, but (there’s) more than $3 billion already in the budget for South Australia to make sure we get that infrastructure that’s needed.

“That’s already in the forward estimates – that’s already baked into the budget in South Australia.”

Marshall was at the official opening of the new Festival Plaza public realm this morning.

He described it as a “once in a generation development” that links Parliament House to the Adelaide Festival Theatre.

The public realm is part of a $663 million Festival Plaza development in partnership with Walker Corporation.

Make a comment View comment guidelines

Local News Matters

Media diversity is under threat in Australia – nowhere more so than in South Australia. The state needs more than one voice to guide it forward and you can help with a donation of any size to InDaily. Your contribution goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. Please click below to help InDaily continue to uncover the facts.

Donate today
Powered by PressPatron

More News stories

Loading next article