Liberal candidate Georgina Downer conceded defeat two hours after the close of the polls, with Sharkie to head back to Canberra after being forced to resign over the dual citizenship saga.
She was expected to finish with about 58 per cent of the two-party-preferred vote, increasing her margin by almost three percentage points after a nine per cent swing on the primary vote.
“I was crushed the day I resigned but today was sweet,” she told supporters in Mt Barker.
“Tonight we have shown that you don’t need lots of money, that you don’t need a big political machine.
“What you need are people who are passionate, people who care.”
Downer said Sharkie put up an extremely good fight to retain the seat.
“Ultimately this was a by-election about the people of Mayo and I absolutely respect their decision,” she said.
“We always knew it would be a particularly challenging campaign.”
Earlier Liberal frontbencher and SA MP Christopher Pyne described Mayo as a “pretty straightforward result”.
“Being an independent (Sharkie) never actually has to disagree with anybody. She can be on everyone’s side on every argument and that always makes it tricky to dislodge an independent,” he told Sky News.
Downer has vowed to stand again at the next federal election in 2019, but will be faced with an even tougher task to return Mayo to the coalition benches.
Despite her family connections to the area – her father Alexander held the seat for 24 years from 1984 – Downer had to counter suggestions she was something of a blow-in after living interstate or overseas for much of the past 20 years.
Sharkie campaigned hard on her background as a long-standing member of the local community, that homespun image appearing to work in her favour.
She was criticised for too often supporting Labor in the parliament, something she, and apparently, the voters, rejected.
Make your contribution to independent news
A donation of any size to InDaily goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. South Australia needs more than one voice to guide it forward, and we’d truly appreciate your contribution. Please click below to donate to InDaily.