England meekly surrendered at the MCG, capitulating for 68 in their second dig as Australia claimed an unassailable 3-0 series lead.
Former England batter Geoffrey Boycott says Root must hand over the reins after Australia won the Ashes series in only 12 days of Test cricket.
“Now Australia are 3-0 up and the Ashes have gone, will Root please stop saying Australia are not much better than us? I don’t mind him living in cuckoo land but stop trying to kid us,” Boycott wrote in his column in The Telegraph.
“If he really believes what he says then maybe it is time he gave up the captaincy of the England cricket team.
“The facts are staring us all in the face, except Joe doesn’t want to see it – England can’t bat. Our bowling is ordinary.
“Nobody would want to give up the captaincy, but it is not about Joe – it is about getting guys to perform better.”
Ex-England batter Mark Ramprakash hopes Root stays on as captain but believes he needs more support.
“Joe’s a great role model but the players around him have not been up to the mark and that’s why… you have to feel sympathetic for him,” he said.
“I don’t think he’s necessarily tactically the best captain we’ve ever had, and so he will have to take his share of responsibility…but equally I think Joe needs support from people above him.
“We need to have a good hard look at how we help Joe Root if he continues as captain… but if he has the drive and desire to carry on then I would stick with him.”
However, ex-England quick Steve Harmison believes heads will roll after their “embarrassing” MCG display.
“There is going to be a big inquest. There’s going to be a lot of things blamed, people’s careers on the line,” said.
“They (Australia) bowled brilliantly but that’s embarrassing, I’m sorry.
“No fight, there was nothing there.”
Former England captain Michael Atherton believed Silverwood would pay dearly for the series loss, saying the blame lay squarely on his shoulders.
After a restructure by men’s managing director Ashley Giles in April, Silverwood absorbed a role as chief selector but England have struggled this year, winning just one of their last 12 Tests with a record nine defeats in 2021 including their MCG nadir.
“I can’t see a situation where Silverwood will survive this tour. All the responsibility lies with him,” Atherton said.
“The way Giles has set things up, there is only one man to blame, even though there are deeper issues than the blame game.”
Local News Matters
Media diversity is under threat in Australia – nowhere more so than in South Australia. The state needs more than one voice to guide it forward and you can help with a donation of any size to InDaily. Your contribution goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. Please click below to help InDaily continue to uncover the facts.