The 160-year-old business was placed into receivership despite annual sales of $380m, with the future of the company’s 1800 staff and 66 locations now in doubt.
Harris Scarfe was bought only a month ago by private equity firm Allegro Funds, as part of its buyout of the general merchandise division of Greenlit Brands.
The stores will trade through Christmas as administrators Deloitte Restructuring Services assesses the business.
Harris Scarfe previously faced closure in 2001, and has had several changes of ownership in recent years.
“We will be making every effort to secure a future for the business and intend to commence an immediate sale of business process,” DRS partner Vaughan Strawbridge said.
Shop, Distributive and Allied Employees Association secretary Josh Peak called for an inquiry into “the role private equity firms are playing in the retail sector in Australia”.
“Only two weeks ago, the new owner informed staff they are the most recognised and awarded turnaround team in Australia and now just weeks later, this has happened,” he said.
But the collapse comes at a difficult time for the retail sector, with research from IBISWorld suggesting the traditionally strong December sales block is on track to deliver an underwhelming result.
“Although inflation has been flat, wages in real terms have barely grown,” IBISWorld senior industry analyst Tom Youl told The New Daily.
“If you take a deeper look at discretionary incomes – the money you have left over after necessary purchases – those have declined.
“The retail sector is really dependent on that discretionary income, which has been declining because consumers’ ability to go out and buy things has been really diminished.”
At the same time, the numbers show consumers are shopping more in November and less in December than they were five years ago.
While that may seem relatively innocuous on the surface, Youl noted that November coincides with the Black Friday and Cyber Monday sales – online shopping extravaganzas that department stores see little to no benefit from.
“For store-based retailers, in all likelihood the good old Boxing Day sale is unlikely to be the saving grace this year,” Youl said.
This year Australians were particularly active in the online sales, with Commonwealth Bank data showing credit card spending lifted 87 per cent on Black Friday compared to the average spend in the three previous weeks.
While the sales bring a spike in credit card use every year, in the past it has averaged only 28 per cent.
‘Death by a thousand cuts’
Retail Doctor Group chief executive Brian Walker said Harris Scarfe’s collapse was “unsurprising, sadly”.
“It’s an older-style retail model, and their customers are more educated and less loyal,” Walker said.
Over the past 10 years the business has targeted itself in regional areas, at Generation X and Baby Boomer customers who are starting to move into retirement and cut back on their spending.
Meanwhile rents have increased, and specialist businesses and online retailers have started to “whittle away” Harris Scarfe’s competitive advantages – and according to Walker, the business was too slow to react.
“I’d compare it to an ocean liner in the harbour – yes, it can be turned around, but it’s going to take time and all the while you have speed boats zipping about and stealing market share,” he said.
“The writing was on the wall about three to five years ago; it’s death by a thousand cuts.”
Rival department stores (including behemoths Myer and David Jones) are battling those same challenges too, Walker added – some better than others.
“Department stores globally are having a tough time of it,” he said.
“Just look to the US closures, to the ones in the UK – this has been happening for the past few years and it’s pretty well documented.”
Most department stores have very few tools to help them survive either, Walker said, with the only realistic options being to cut costs, renegotiate rents and close stores.
Woolworths-backed Big W has already announced the closure of 30 stores in a bid to keep costs down, and Myer’s executive team is working on a radical plan to right their formerly sinking ship.
–with The New Daily
Want to comment?
Send us an email, making it clear which story you’re commenting on and including your full name (required for publication) and phone number (only for verification purposes). Please put “Reader views” in the subject.
We’ll publish the best comments in a regular “Reader Views” post. Your comments can be brief, or we can accept up to 350 words, or thereabouts.
InDaily has changed the way we receive comments. Go here for an explanation.
Help our journalists uncover the facts
In times like these InDaily provides valuable, local independent journalism in South Australia. As a news organisation it offers an alternative to The Advertiser, a different voice and a closer look at what is happening in our city and state for free. Any contribution to help fund our work is appreciated. Please click below to donate to InDaily.