John Mendoza's resignation
Adjunct Professor John Mendoza – who walked out of his office last week rather than obey an SA Health order to shut up – says action is needed now – “not in two or three years”.
“I will not go silently – I have a duty of care to the staff at Central Adelaide Local Health Network and an obligation to the community to call for real action by our governments to meet the mental health needs in the shadow of the COVID pandemic,” he said this morning.
As revealed in InDaily last week, Mendoza quit one year into his three-year post as mental health executive director for the Central Adelaide Local Health Network, citing significant concerns within the system and unleashing on authorities for a lack of commitment to reform.
“I’m not going to waste my time in a sense pretending I’m part of some reform effort when it’s not there,” he told InDaily at the time.
“I think it’s time this was called out. I think it’s time there is some accountability on the department and the chief executive and the minister.”
Providing a copy of his plan (outlined below) to InDaily, Mendoza this morning said that with so much uncertainty now over the COVID vaccine rollout, the mental health impacts of the pandemic would “step up again” and “the economic hit will be much longer”.
He said it was “absolutely fundamental to the future of the state there is assertive action now”.
“These are statewide issues and continuing neglect of them will see the situation go from crisis to emergency this year,” he said.
Mendoza said none of what he’s now calling for is contained in the state’s existing Mental Health Services Plan, because it was written before the pandemic.
He urged Health Minister Stephen Wade to take decisive and immediate action.
“The Minister also (recently) referred to the work at a Commonwealth level with the states and territories following the Productivity Commission report,” he said.
“Well the governments have had that report for eight months. The report makes little reference to the pandemic as most of its work was in 2018-19.
“Again, too little, too slow. Plus it is the same committees that have responsibility for mental health reform for the past 30 years and they have dismally failed.”
He fired another shot at SA Health overnight on Twitter, calling the department “by far the most ossified and inept central portfolio agency in my 28-year state and Commonwealth public sector career and 15 years of consultancy work”.
“That’s worst out of 30-plus state and federal central agencies,” he said.
“Quite an achievement.”
He tagged Health Minister Stephen Wade, saying “very sad for your state”.
. @SAHealth is by far the most ossified & inept central portfolio agency in my 28-year state & Commonwealth public sector career & 15 years of consultancy work. That's worst out of 30+ state & Federal central agencies. Quite an achievement. Very sad for ur state @StephenWadeMLC
— John Mendoza (@johno0910) April 12, 2021
But Wade refused to be drawn on it, saying: “Professor Mendoza is entitled to his opinion. I just make the point that he came to South Australia less than a year ago.”
When InDaily pointed out that it was his government that had hired Mendoza, who now thinks so poorly of his department, Wade said: “As I said, he’s entitled to his opinion.”
On Mendoza’s 10-point plan, Wade said: “My understanding is the plan that’s been published is substantially the same as the plan that was provided to the Department of Health and Wellbeing and the Department of Health and Wellbeing has responded.”
In a statement, a spokesperson for SA Health said “the majority of suggestions outlined in the 10-point plan are addressed in the Mental Health Services Plan (MHSP) or through initiatives within our Local Health Networks”.
“The MHSP has been developed by mental health leaders, clinicians and other stakeholders including people with lived experience,” the spokesperson said.
“It was widely consulted and is now well into implementation phase.
“Only last month, the Urgent Mental Health Care Centre opened.
“The modelling used for the MHSP also gives priorities to services for children and adolescents and older people and the plan considers country areas, and changes to the work of SA non-government services and government services.
“The Government has responded to the mental health impact of COVID-19 in financial year 2020 – 2021 with a $15.102 million plan that has been allocated across a range of mental health initiatives.”
Mendoza’s 10-point plan:
1. Forensic means Forensic
- Transfer all forensic mental health patients out of general hospitals and into forensic mental health services by the end of April.
Mendoza says SA Health and the Correctional Services Department will have to “purchase” or set up additional capacity “now” – “not in two or three years”.
Cost: Not estimated
2. Specialist beds for the most unwell patients
- Open at least eight additional psychiatric intensive care beds now for the Central Adelaide Local Health Network and country and rural local health networks.
Mendoza says a module unit can be in place in 12 weeks at Glenside.
He says this would “reduce 90 per cent of bed blocks for the needs of these very unwell patients”.
Cost: Annualised cost per bed $400,000 – total $3.2m
3. Mobilise an additional workforce
- Use unplaced graduate nurses
- Rapid 6-week up-skilling program
- Extra allied health positions
- Recruit overseas specialists where needed
- Increase the number of graduate traineeships for nurses
- Invest in rapid development of the peer specialist workforce
4. Think big, start small, scale fast
- Rapidly scale up a number of proven programs to slow flow of demand to metropolitan emergency departments
- Increase GP mental health nurse liaison, from two teams in CALHN to six across metro and hills
- Extend mental heath co-responder programs – that partner specialist mental health staff with paramedics – from the current two vehicles on one extended shift per day across Adelaide to six vehicles and working across two shifts
- Set up two trials of GP psychiatry liaison, similar to a model operating in Sydney
- Scale up “Hospital in the Home” program from 12 beds to 36
Cost: annualised $7m
5. Housing First
- Stand up emergency accommodation for an initial 100 people across the metro area working with homeless service providers.
- Expand this on as needed and uncapped basis for the rest of 2021-22.
Mendoza says this was “exactly what was done at height of pandemic” and that there is a “vast amount of vacant student accommodation on every street which may be suitable and immediately available prior to the cooler and wetter months”.
Cost: Not estimated but based on Perth’s experience, savings of $2.50 for every $1 invested.
6. Non-ambulance transfers for Mental Health Patients
- Approve CALHN’s procurement of “non-stretcher transport” for mental health patients – then extend it metro-wide.
Mendoza says “South Australia is the only jurisdiction still exclusively using stretcher-based transport for all mental health patients”.
“This is a totally unnecessary and harmful,” he says.
“It is a contributing factor to the very high number of mental health patients subject to coercive and restrictive practices in this state under sections and involuntary treatment orders.
“Our public services are actively doing harm to unwell people.”
Cost: A saving for CALHN in a year of $1.7m. Statewide $3m+.
7. A Real NDIS Taskforce
- Free up beds occupied by NDIS clients.
Mendoza says more than 50 beds – nearly a third of the total capacity across CALHN – are occupied by NDIS ready and/or eligible clients.
“Some have been stuck for over a thousand days in a small room,” he says.
“The average length of stay for 40 of these patients is over 620 days and 26 of them are over 900 days. This is deplorable and a violation of human rights.”
He says additional Allied Health (AH) specialist resources are needed to move the NDIS waitlist.
“I have seen nothing happen on this front for nearly two years,” he says.
“SA has the worst transfer of state supported Mental Health clients across to NDIS. Less than 40% after three years. NDIS paperwork is onerous and requires a four to five fold increase in specialist Allied Health resources.
“Freeing CALHN and statewide beds of these NDIS patients will immediately unblock the system.”
Cost: $400,000 for 6.7 staff for just one year. The Return on Investment is calculated at greater than $12 saved for every $1 spent.
8. First Responder Up-Skilling
- Replicate a QLD training system for police including:
A four-hour mental health awareness program
A two-day mental health first aid training
Advanced skills in mental health for some officers
Mendoza says the QLD police service has then “connected every police vehicle to the QLD Health database to enable them to be informed about the person they may be engaged to see or visit”.
“They have some co-responder teams and in many regions they now have dedicated Vulnerable Persons Units who work exclusively with domestic violence perpetrators and people living with severe mental illness,” he says.
“It is world-class and it must be replicated in South Australia to improve SAPOL’s capacity to response to the most common call on its staff – mental illness.
“Mental health and suicide related issues and domestic violence accounts for almost 90 per cent of police work. Police need to be supported to undertake this work.”
Cost: $1 million initially
9. How to Manage the Surge – a Plan would be good
- Apply advanced modelling to regions in SA to understand the likely impact of job losses, income reductions, mortgage stress and business closures.
Mendoza says “currently these is no plan based on robust data analysis”.
“That has to change,” he says.
“We will then have a clearer understanding of demands and can anticipate the range of health and social needs that will develop over coming years.”
10. COVID Mental Health Response Centre
- Establish a special COVID Mental Health Response Centre (CMHRC) to undertake continuous surveillance and reporting, coordinate pubic education campaigns and mobilise extra resources when needed
- Restructure the Office of the Chief Psychiatrist in line with other states
Cost: $1m per year
Local News Matters
Media diversity is under threat in Australia – nowhere more so than in South Australia. The state needs more than one voice to guide it forward and you can help with a donation of any size to InDaily. Your contribution goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. Please click below to contribute to InDaily.