InDaily InDaily

Support independent Journalism Donate Subscribe
Support independent journalism


Not enough SA talent as Transport boss defends Sydney-based "million-dollar-club"


The State Government is spending millions of dollars on high-level Sydney-based contractors because “the local talent pool is not up the task”, the head of SA’s transport department has told parliament.

Print article

Appearing before parliament’s Budget and Finance Committee this morning, the CE of the newly-reconfigured Infrastructure and Transport Department defended the appointments of what the Opposition described as a “million-dollar-club” of senior contractors, who have all been working remotely from Sydney amid coronavirus border restrictions.

Tony Braxton-Smith conceded three “single-source” appointments had all previously worked at Transport NSW at the same time as him, and had subsequently been contracted to the SA department since his arrival.

One of them, Peter Andrews, was contracted as director of the bus services procurement project for $1.08 million, while NZ Transport Agency chief Fergus Gammie is being paid $1.47 million to direct the state’s rail privatisation project.

Both are primarily based in Sydney, along with another recent appointment, State Planning Reform Director Ray Partridge, whose agency has since shifted out of the Transport Department as part of a restructure after the resignation of former minister Stephan Knoll.

Ray Partridge. Photo: Supplied

Braxton-Smith defended the hand-picked appointments, saying all three were “highly-skilled individuals providing their skills and experiences for work where there was no-one in the state with the required skills and experience”.

But he was quizzed by Opposition frontbencher Kyam Maher who noted that “all these people who work from Sydney also have the added benefit of working with you, Mr Braxton-Smith, in the past”, asking: “Do you think it’s a good look?”

“I think the state expects us to find the right people to do the job, and do the job well,” Braxton-Smith responded.

“There was no-one found in a market-based process locally that has the skills and experience where the form of the contract is highly specialised… likewise in development and delivery of software, the local talent pool was not up to the task.

“We had to find someone at short notice who had experience with complex program delivery, complex software development as well as reform.”

He said while he had worked with Partridge in the past, that appointment was made by Planning executive director Sally Smith as a “direct appointment in accordance with the provisions of the SA Public Service Act”.

Asked why “we so rarely see [any of the appointees] in Adelaide”, Braxton-Smith said that was because of “restrictions on travel associated with COVID”.

“We have a remote working arrangement, and we also have a COVID-safe plan,” he said.

Gammie faces the committee from Sydney. Photo: Tony Lewis / InDaily

Maher cited now-Treasurer Rob Lucas, who in 2016 was critical of the former Labor Government for allowing then-CE of the Premier’s department Don Russell to commute to SA from his Sydney home.

“Having someone who flees… to go back home each weekend just isn’t good enough,” Lucas told The Advertiser at the time.

“We want someone in that key role who champions the state and understands its issues… we need someone who lives the state’s problems.”

Lucas told InDaily today: “I always stand by whatever I said at the time [but] I won’t enter into any further comment about current arrangements.”

“I’m not going to generalise – the comments I would have made certainly would have applied to the most senior public servant, the CE of the Department of Premier and Cabinet, but I won’t generalise anywhere beyond the most senior public servant in the state…

“I’m sure whatever I said at the time was applicable to the most senior person.”

Want to comment?

Send us an email, making it clear which story you’re commenting on and including your full name (required for publication) and phone number (only for verification purposes). Please put “Reader views” in the subject.

We’ll publish the best comments in a regular “Reader Views” post. Your comments can be brief, or we can accept up to 350 words, or thereabouts.

Make a comment View comment guidelines

Local News Matters

Media diversity is under threat in Australia – nowhere more so than in South Australia. The state needs more than one voice to guide it forward and you can help with a donation of any size to InDaily. Your contribution goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. Please click below to help InDaily continue to uncover the facts.

Donate today
Powered by PressPatron

More News stories

Loading next article