Adelaide's independent news


Us versus them: Weatherill crash tackles Frydenberg


Premier Jay Weatherill has aggressively upped the ante in his energy plan sales pitch, going toe-to-toe with federal Energy Minister Josh Frydenberg during an Adelaide press conference which was broadcast live across the country today.

Comments Print article

In a dramatic escalation of federal-state tensions, Weatherill and Frydenberg traded insults on the sources of South Australia’s energy problems.

The event was called to promote energy company AGL’s trial of battery technology in Adelaide’s suburbs, but Weatherill quickly made it all about ‘us versus them’ – a favourite theme of the Premier who previously used it to his political advantage before the 2014 state election.

In one of his angriest public displays in recent memory, Weatherill slammed the Federal Government, with a stony-faced Frydenberg at his shoulder, and a sometimes smirking state Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis in the background.

He hijacked the event in a fashion which both promoted his $550 million energy plan announced this week and accelerated the disintegration of the relationship between the state and federal governments on energy policy.

Frydenberg and Weatherill both claimed to be surprised to see each other at the event, which turned away from the issue at hand to an out-and-out verbal fight.

“To be honest, I didn’t even know Jay was going to be here,” Frydenberg said.

Weatherill said the same: “I didn’t realise Mr Frydenberg was coming.”

For nearly 20 minutes the pair stood side-by-side sledging each other, watched on by Koutsantonis and smiling AGL boss Andy Vesey.

“I feel that the premier trying to come into this to crash tackle us at this announcement where he hasn’t put any money into this important initiative, which the commonwealth and AGL have, just shows you, unfortunately, how desperate he is,” Frydenberg said.

The minister also talked up Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s announcement for a $2 billion expansion of the Snowy Hydro scheme, denying it was made today to embarrass the state government.

Weatherill labelled the announcement evidence of “white knuckled panic” from the commonwealth over energy policy.

“I have to say it is a little galling to be standing here next to a man who has been standing up with his prime minister bagging SA at every step of the way over the last six months,” he said.

“It is a disgrace the way in which your government has treated our state. It’s the most anti-South Australian government we have seen from a Commonwealth Government in living memory. “

South Australia can’t wait for a Snowy Hydro expansion four to seven years down the track, he argued.

“We have a plan to make SA self-sufficient, to stand on our own two feet today and that is what we’re getting on with.”

But Frydenberg bristled and hit back.

“The premier made a $550 million admission of failure a couple of days ago,” he said, awkwardly refusing to make eye contact with the man he was talking about.

Weatherill, however, used that rhetoric in return, saying the Federal Government’s plan to expand the Snowy Hydro scheme was a “$2 billion admission” that the national energy market is broken and needs government investment.

The Premier also got personal, harking back to last year’s confusion about the possibility of an energy intensity scheme.

Frydenberg had supported a discussion of such a scheme in the Finkel review of the national energy market, before the idea was quickly scrapped.

Weatherill said this must have been “a source of humiliation” for Frydenberg to be “cut down” by his prime minister.

Both men walked off without exchanging goodbyes, with Frydenberg taking one final shot.

“Maybe Tom will be the next premier of South Australia because I think after Jay Weatherill’s conduct today, the public would think that is pretty unbecoming, pretty childish and pretty unacceptable for a senior political figure of their state to behave.”

– with AAP





We value local independent journalism. We hope you do too.

InDaily provides valuable, local independent journalism in South Australia. As a news organisation it offers an alternative to The Advertiser, a different voice and a closer look at what is happening in our city and state for free. Any contribution to help fund our work is appreciated. Please click below to become an InDaily supporter.

Powered by PressPatron


Show comments Hide comments
Will my comment be published? Read the guidelines.

More News stories

Loading next article