The recommendation is one of 129 suggested changes in the 332-page report of an independent liquor licensing review being considered by the Government.
Other proposals include consideration of a national minimum price for alcohol, alcohol advertising bans for public transport, a “name and shame” list of operators caught breaching licensing conditions, tougher penalties for licensees caught selling alcohol to a minor, and allowing pubs to open on Good Friday and Christmas Day.
Currently, it is illegal to serve a drunk person alcohol, but the recommendation proposes going further to require all licensed venues – including those hosting wedding receptions, wine tastings and birthday parties – to throw out any intoxicated person.
Under the proposal, it would be an offence to “allow a person who is in a state of intoxication to be on the licensed premises”.
“We just think it’s draconian,” Australian Hotels Association SA general manager Ian Horne told InDaily.
“The licensee should absolutely not serve [a drunk person] any more alcohol, but to remove them? Throw them out into the street?
“It’s dangerous. It’s brutish.”
Horne said the proposal would open licensees up to extraordinary risk, and force people to be unnecessarily expelled from weddings, birthdays, corporate and sporting events, and wine tastings, as well as pubs and clubs.
“Everyone in the liquor industry would be opposed to that,” Horne said.
“If you have a [wedding] reception at any licensed venue … the caterer will be obliged to … remove intoxicated people.
“Which could include the bride … if not the father-in-law.
“The entire wedding party might have to be kicked out, depending on the circumstances.
“What do you do at the RSL on ANZAC Day?
“We just can’t see that there’s any justification for it.”
He said it wasn’t clear how “intoxicated” a person would have to be to get kicked out, but that under the recommendation, licensees would have no legal defence if someone is found to be drunk in their venue.
The review also recommends more high-visibility police patrolling streets and entering venues, a law to force anyone who “appears to be” under the age of 25 to produce photo identification, and giving police the power to breathalyse bartenders and licensees.
Former Supreme Court Judge Tim Anderson writes in the review that, “paradoxically, while a person who is controlling entry to licensed premises can be tested by police and must have a zero drug and alcohol level, a person responsible for actually managing and supervising the sale and supply of liquor is not subject to such scrutiny”.
“The most glaring example of a responsible person drinking on the job comes from the recent prosecution of the Penneshaw Hotel and the responsible person on duty, a Mr Richard Purvis,” Anderson writes.
“It was alleged that Mr Purvis continued to serve the customer liquor when he was clearly intoxicated and also was drinking alcohol himself whilst performing the duties of a responsible person.
“Mr Purvis and the licensee pleaded guilty to the allegation that a customer was continuously being served liquor to the extent that he subsequently crashed his car on leaving the hotel with a blood alcohol reading of 0.292.
“The customer died from injuries sustained in the crash.”
However, Horne said the AHA was also “totally against” breathalysing licensees and their employees, a proposal he described as adding “more red tape” and preventing cellar-door guides from tasting wine while hosting a wine tasting.
The review also recommends spreading small bar licences to North Adelaide and allowing restaurants to sell alcohol to patrons without necessarily selling them food.
In addition, it recommends:
- A feasibility study into extending public transport hours beyond midnight for many Adelaide Metro bus services.
- A simplification of the licensing system, reducing the number of liquor licences – from 12 to eight – to include a “BYO” permit.
- Expanding police powers to enter residences and venues where they believe supply of alcohol to minors may be occurring.
- Cutting local councils out of the liquor licensing process, quarantining their influence to the planning stage.
- Allowing local councils to declare temporary – maximum 48-hour – alcohol-free zones for child-friendly events such as the Christmas Pageant.
- A national review of alcohol advertising during live sport telecasts.
- Mandated digital scanning of ID cards after 1am.
- A 10pm cut-off time for the sale of alcohol at bottle shops.
- Having all liquor licence applications made using a single form.
- Exempting retirement villages and cruise ships from applying for liquor licences.
The State Government is currently considering the review, which can be read here.
Local News Matters
Media diversity is under threat in Australia – nowhere more so than in South Australia. The state needs more than one voice to guide it forward and you can help with a donation of any size to InDaily. Your contribution goes directly to helping our journalists uncover the facts. Please click below to contribute to InDaily.